I am a huge fan of blending. However, once a student can blend taught sounds, move them on to reading words as a whole for meaning, with fluency and in meaningful text. Morphological units can be easily incorporated into blending instruction. Blending is the tool to unlock the code not the end goal. I’ve seen teachers have students segment and blend too many words once the student has mastered a taught sequence. Always teach blending along with segmenting.
Regarding teaching onset-rime instruction, I read the Shanahan article that you referenced, and agree with him when he stated “I have no doubt that if kids in a synthetic phonics program had trouble with blending, then the teaching of some larger word units (rimes, syllables, multi-letter morphemes) could help.” I have promoted and witnessed success for many students using this approach.
Susan, thanks for the comment. I agree that teachers should not dwell on blending as an end. It's just a means to build rapid decoding work. Indeed, we should, move on to blending larger units (especially high frequency sound sequences that learners will encounter during word reading), some of which might be words themselves (e.g., "/o/+/l/+/d/") and also "rimes."
I am a huge fan of blending. However, once a student can blend taught sounds, move them on to reading words as a whole for meaning, with fluency and in meaningful text. Morphological units can be easily incorporated into blending instruction. Blending is the tool to unlock the code not the end goal. I’ve seen teachers have students segment and blend too many words once the student has mastered a taught sequence. Always teach blending along with segmenting.
Regarding teaching onset-rime instruction, I read the Shanahan article that you referenced, and agree with him when he stated “I have no doubt that if kids in a synthetic phonics program had trouble with blending, then the teaching of some larger word units (rimes, syllables, multi-letter morphemes) could help.” I have promoted and witnessed success for many students using this approach.
One size doesn’t fit all.
Susan, thanks for the comment. I agree that teachers should not dwell on blending as an end. It's just a means to build rapid decoding work. Indeed, we should, move on to blending larger units (especially high frequency sound sequences that learners will encounter during word reading), some of which might be words themselves (e.g., "/o/+/l/+/d/") and also "rimes."
I love the /o/+/l//+/d/ - we don’t know anyone like that. 😂 old is a closed syllable exception- the vowel is long- not usual short vowel.